The Sheriffs Bluff 1908 — Story, Setting & Ideas

(0 User reviews)   54
Page, Thomas Nelson, 1853-1922 Project Gutenberg 2007 Not confirmed
Short stories; Southern States -- Social life and customs -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 9,205
Reading time 41 min
Text sections 2

The Sheriffs Bluff 1908 — Story, Setting & Ideas can be approached with a clearer sense of reading commitment from its source measurements: 9,205 words, 41 min estimated reading time, and 2 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 18.7 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Short stories,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

In this 1908 short story, Thomas Nelson Page uses a bluff to expose the gap between legal authority and social performance in a Southern county, where the sheriff's audacious courtroom trick becomes a local legend.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.4/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

designs himself on Sam Jefford's buxom, black-eyed daughter, while others held that he was afraid of young Dick, who was an amiable and popular young fellow, and that he did not want him to get too much influence in the lower end of the county. However it was, Mary Jefford not only married her young lover, but sobered him, and as she was young, pretty, and ambitious, and worshipped her husband, Dick Creel at the next election, to use the vernacular, “made cornsideruble show runnin' ag'inst the Sheriff, and give him cornsideruble trouble.” Still, Thompson was elected overwhelmingly, and few people believed Mary Creel's charge that the Sheriff had got Dick drunk on purpose to beat him. Thompson said, “Did n't anybody have to _git_ Dick drunk--the work was t'other way.”

The session of the Circuit Court in the “------ year of the Commonwealth,” as the writs ran, and “in the sixteenth year of Aleck Thompson's Sheriffalty,” as that official used to say, was more than usually important. The noted case of “_Dolittle et al. vs. Dolittle's Executrix_” was tried at the autumn term of the court, and caused considerable excitement in the county; for, in addition to the amount of property and the nice questions of law which were involved, the two sides had been severally espoused by two sister churches, and nearly half the county was in attendance, either as witnesses or interested spectators. Not only was every available corner in the little village filled to overflowing with parties, witnesses, and their adherents, but during the first week of the term the stable yards and road-sides were lined with covered wagons and other vehicles, in or under which some of those who had not been fortunate enough to obtain shelter in the inn used to sleep, and “Briles's bar” under the tavern did a thriving business.

As the case, however, wore on, and the weather became inclement, the crowd dropped off somewhat, though a sufficient number still remained to give an air of life to the little roadside village.

Certain of these visitors found the bar-room on the ground floor of the tavern across the road more attractive than the court-room, and as evening came the loud talking in that direction told that the visits had not been fruitless.

Perfect order, however, prevailed in the court, until one evening one of these visitors, a young man named Turkle, who had been spending the afternoon at the bar, made his way into the court-room. He was clad in a dingy, weather-stained overcoat and an old slouch hat. He sank into a seat at the end of a bench near the door and, being very drunk, soon began to talk aloud to those about him.

“Silence!” called the Sheriff over the heads of the crowd from his desk in front, and those near the man cautioned him to stop talking. A moment later, however, he began again. Again the Sheriff roared “Silence!” But by this time the hot air of the court-room had warmed up Mr. Turkle, and in answer to the warning of those about him, he declared in a maudlin tone, that he “Warn't goin' to keep silence.”

“I got 's much right to talk 's anyone, and I'ma goin' to talk 's much 's I please.”

His friends tried to silence him, and the Sheriff made his way through the crowd and endeavored to induce him to leave the court-room. But it was to no purpose. Jim Turkle was much too “far gone” to know what he was doing, though he was in a delightfully good humor. He merely hugged the Sheriff and laughed drunkenly.

“Aleck, you jist go 'way f'om here. I ain't a-goin' to shet up. You shet up yourself. I 'm a-goin' to talk all I please. Now, you hear it.”

Then as if to atone for his rudeness, he caught the Sheriff roughly by the arm and pulled him toward him:

“Aleck, how 's the case goin'? Is Mandy a goin' to win? Is that old rascal rulin' right!”

The Sheriff urged something in a low voice, but Turkle would not be silenced.

“Now you see thar,” he broke out with a laugh to those about him, “did n't I tell you Aleck wa' n 't nothin' but a' ol' drunkard? What d' you s'pose the ol' rascal wants me to do? He wants me to go over there to the bar and git drunk like 'im, and I ain't goin' to do it. I never drink. I 've come here to see that my cousin Mandy's chil'ern gits their patrimony, and I ain' a goin' to 'sociate with these here drunken fellows like Aleck Thompson.”

The Sheriff made a final effort. He spoke positively, but Turkle would not heed.

The opening of Thomas Nelson Page's The Sheriff's Bluff dwells on the physical relics of a colonial past—the courthouse, the jail, the judge, and the sheriff—each described with exaggerated, almost mythic weight. The jail is a "cube of stone" with bars "massive enough to have come from the Pyramid of Cheops," while the judge retains ruffles and a demeanor that "lent dignity to the Bar." Yet the story that follows undercuts this solemnity: the sheriff, Aleck Thompson, pulls off a bluff in court that becomes the talk of the term. The catalog subjects list "Southern States -- Social life and customs," and the excerpts do show local politics and gossip, but the focus is less on broad customs than on a single, clever deception and its social aftermath.

Colonial Relics and Comic Undermining

The story's first paragraphs establish a setting steeped in the past: the courthouse "might have stood before a temple of Minerva," and the judge is a "relic of the past" whose life "had been one of high rectitude and dignity." This weighty description primes the reader for a tale of gravitas. Yet the plot quickly pivots to a comic bluff. Sheriff Thompson, facing a witness who might expose his own drunken night in jail, impersonates the judge in court to prevent the testimony. The contrast between the opening's monumental tone and the sheriff's farcical trick is striking. The catalog subject "Historical" fits the setting, but the excerpts show that history here serves as a backdrop for a light, almost farcical episode rather than a serious historical drama.

The Bluff as Social Currency

After the bluff succeeds, the story tracks its social ripple. Thompson's trick becomes "the topic of the rest of the term," and his re-election is deemed "certain." One adherent declares, "That Aleck Thompson 's the smartest man that is." The bluff is not condemned but celebrated as a display of "audacity" and "resourcefulness." The catalog subject "Social life and customs" is evident in the courthouse-green gossip and the tavern parlor scene, but the excerpts emphasize that the community values cleverness over truth. Even the sheriff's wife, Mary Creel, arrives to confront him, and the story ends with the judge unsuspecting. The bluff functions as a form of social capital, reshaping local opinion and securing Thompson's popularity.

Voice and Regional Speech Patterns

Page renders dialogue in a distinct vernacular that marks character and region. Dick Creel says, "Whiskey is a queer thing. I must have been a lot drunker than I thought I was." The sheriff's wife insists on being called "Mrs. Creel" with a "glint in her black eyes." The narrator also uses colloquial phrasing: "Jest a settin' and a waitin'." This speech is not merely decorative; it drives the humor and the power dynamics. The bluff itself relies on the sheriff's ability to mimic the judge's formal tone. The catalog subject "Short stories" is accurate, but the excerpts reveal that the story's texture comes from the interplay between formal narration and rustic dialogue, a feature not captured by the subject headings alone.

Readers should attend to how Page balances the story's opening grandeur with its comic core. The bluff is the engine of the plot, but the excerpts leave unclear whether the sheriff faces lasting consequences from his wife or the judge. The incomplete text ends with the judge still "unsuspecting," suggesting that the bluff may have longer repercussions. The story rewards attention to its layered voices—the narrator's stately descriptions versus the characters' earthy speech—and to the way a single act of deception reshapes a community's perception of authority.

There are afternoons when I think of Page’s sheriff, that bluff born of necessity, and I’m reminded how a town’s whispered tales outlast its statutes. Bred in the bone 1908 — Text and Context keeps such company quietly on my shelf, both books breathing the same dusty air of a county that trusted performance over paper.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

Before you leave, reflect on the book

Use these questions to collect your thoughts before moving on.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

How far have you progressed with this book?

2

Was reading this book enjoyable?

3

Would you recommend this book to another reader?

4

How easy was the book to follow?

Related eBooks